Paper VII visual guide · Visual 9 of 40 · HOW TWO PATH AMPLITUDES CANCEL

Why path probabilities do not add

Traditional edition: Theorem II.4.2, Theorem II.4.4.

Start reading

Resources & source

Original plate in the monograph PDF · Original atlas source

Skip contents and start reading

Two consecutive Hadamard gates multiply to the identity. Starting from \({\left|0\right\rangle}\), there are two resolved paths to output \({\left|1\right\rangle}\). Their signed products are

\[ {\left\langle1\right|}H_{\rm Had}{\left|0\right\rangle}{\left\langle0\right|}H_{\rm Had}{\left|0\right\rangle}=\frac12, \qquad {\left\langle1\right|}H_{\rm Had}{\left|1\right\rangle}{\left\langle1\right|}H_{\rm Had}{\left|0\right\rangle}=-\frac12. \]

Their sum is zero. Squaring each separately gives a different answer.

Two signed Hadamard paths cancel at one output.
Original drawing. Read the description below; expand the labels and data for selectable text.

Reading the drawing

The diagram branches through the two intermediate addresses and recombines at the selected output. One second-stage amplitude has a minus sign. The comparison below separates the sum of amplitudes from a sum of path probabilities.

Drawing labels and data 10 labels

Read the original labels as selectable text. Tables preserve grid relationships; other short labels are grouped compactly.

  • \(0\)
  • \(0\)
  • \(1\)
  • \(1\)
  • \(1/\sqrt2\)
  • \(1/\sqrt2\)
  • \(1/\sqrt2\)
  • \(-1/\sqrt2\)

Two actual Hadamard paths, not classical alternatives

\[\text{amplitude}=1/2-1/2=0\quad\ne\quad\text{sum of path probabilities}=1/2\]

Open the full-size drawing

Where the missing term goes

For path amplitudes \(a,b\), the outcome probability is \(|a+b|^2=|a|^2+|b|^2+2\Re(a\bar b)\). Here the last term is \(-1/2\), canceling the first two terms. The path picture retains this information only if its edges carry complex amplitudes rather than unsigned reachability or probabilities.

The packetwise unitarity identity is likewise an operator identity, including the off-diagonal cancellations:

\[ \sum_b U_{ba}^*U_{bc}=\delta_{ac}P_a, \qquad U_{ba}=P_bUP_a. \]

It cannot be replaced by the assertion that every path individually has unit norm. The exact checks verify all four choices of \(a,c\) for the two rank-one packets, as well as the two path products leading to the opposite output.

A measurement at the intermediate stage would remove the cross term. In that modified experiment the two alternatives really would contribute total probability \(1/2\) to output one. Adding the two path probabilities would therefore describe the experiment with an intermediate measurement.

Read this as

Insert projectors algebraically to resolve paths, then add amplitudes. Add probabilities only when the physical setup has actually made the alternatives incoherent.

Source and conversion record

The original atlas wording, equations, and drawing labels are retained. Drawings are views of the frozen monograph PDF. Text descriptions and table headings are added reading aids. This conversion does not rebuild TeX, rerun the examples, audit proofs or compile Lean.

Conversion checks and source hashes

Notation in Paper VII

Look up a symbol without leaving this chapter. Select text before opening help to search for it.

Search this work’s notation.

    Symbols can have different meanings in different passages. Read each result in its own context.

    Open the full notation index