Paper XII visual guide · Visual 27 of 27 · VALIDATION / FOUR DISTINCT KINDS OF EVIDENCE

How to assess the evidence

Inherited source records, current illustrative calculations and final editorial review Main statement 12.6

Recorded evidence for Paper XII

Start reading

Resources & source

Original plate in the visual-guide PDF · Original atlas source

Skip contents and start reading

What this companion adds and what its checks mean

The guide preserves the earlier worked examples. TikZ generates every drawing from exact objects; there are no raster figures. Python checks finite enumerations, minors, projectors and matrices; the text argues uniform conclusions. These checks supply no new Lean certificate or census update. Supporting Markdown (.md) files accompany the source.

Read this as

The source's internal formal implications are distinguished from the arithmetic inputs: representability, residual occupancy, applicable patching, classicality, attached representations and compatible systems, Frobenius density, semisimplification and Brauer–Nesbitt. Universal companions and unrestricted reciprocity remain outside the proved scope.

Inherited labels and current mathematical judgments

The original-status labels record historical verification coverage. The current mathematical audit judges the actual statements. These are different questions:

V27: How to assess the evidence
OriginalInherited labelCurrent statement-level judgment
6.12uncheckedThe reversed containment is false: in the node of V–9, \(M=R\) has full support, which is not contained in either single component.
10.5partialThe unrestricted effectivity conclusion lacks the coefficient, continuity, integrality and frame hypotheses made explicit in the revision.

Use each check for its actual subject

V27: How to assess the evidence
EvidenceWhat its subject is
Inherited Lean recordThe mapped revised statements under their supplied hypotheses. This guide neither replays that build nor changes the original-wording record.
Current exact Python checksForty-six illustrative assertions: 31 inherited checks and 15 added checks on the printed finite examples and identities.
Mathematical argumentsUniform quotient, specialization and all-level conclusions, with their hypotheses retained in the text. A finite diagram is not an infinite proof.
PDF and rebuild checksTopic alignment, bounds, vector-only assets, resolved references, and an isolated byte/text/page comparison. These are document checks.

The supporting README.md gives portable rebuild commands. The source-coverage Markdown and JSON map all 49 internal claims to this guide's reading entries and exact manuscript labels. The audit records dependency versions, mathematical self-review and complete-page inspection. No finite calculation here verifies residual automorphic existence, classicality, attached compatible systems, or a universal arithmetic theorem.

Source and conversion record

The original atlas wording, equations, and drawing labels are retained. Drawings are views of the retained visual-guide PDF. Text descriptions and table headings are added reading aids. This conversion does not rebuild TeX, rerun the examples, audit proofs or compile Lean.

The guide contains 27 plates and 23 drawings: 21 from separate drawing files and two embedded directly in the page source. The unused rotated-support sketch is retained in the source archive. The final claim-delta and evidence pages preserve the distinction between the revised contract and the historical original wording.

Conversion checks and source hashes

Notation in Paper XII

Look up a symbol without leaving this chapter. Select text before opening help to search for it.

Search this work’s notation.

    Symbols can have different meanings in different passages. Read each result in its own context.

    Open the full notation index