Paper VIIReading edition

Moving packets, connections, and curvature

Reading tools
Reading libraryFind statementsInspect Lean
Switch work

Saved reading

Read side by side

Start reading

Resources & source

Original TeX with line links · Download TeX

The wording and mathematics follow the retained manuscript. This reading format does not add a proof review or extend Lean coverage.

Skip contents and start reading

I.6 Moving packets, connections, and curvature

I.6.1 Moving quantum coordinates

Theorem I.6.1: Moving-frame Hamiltonian

Let \(U(t)\) and \(\psi(t)\) be differentiable on an open real time interval, let \(U(t)\) be unitary, and let \(H(t)=H(t)^*\). Suppose

\[ i\dot\psi(t)=H(t)\psi(t). \]

Writing

\[ \psi(t)=U(t)y(t) \]

gives

\[ \boxed{ i\dot y(t) = \left(U(t)^*H(t)U(t)-iU(t)^*\dot U(t)\right)y(t). } \]

Both the connection term \(-iU^*\dot U\) and the effective Hamiltonian \(U^*HU-iU^*\dot U\) are Hermitian.

Proof of Theorem I.6.1

Differentiate \(\psi=Uy\):

\[ i\dot U y+iU\dot y=HUy. \]

Multiplying by \(U^*\) gives the formula. Differentiating \(U^*U=I\) shows \(U^*\dot U\) is skew-Hermitian, so \(-iU^*\dot U\) is Hermitian.

Moving-frame equation residuals with and without the connection term.
The equation in the moving frame holds to numerical precision only when the connection term is retained.
Text description

Two bars use a logarithmic residual axis. Retaining the connection gives a residual near numerical precision; omitting it gives a much larger residual. The comparison isolates the connection term in the moving-coordinate equation.

Open original figure (PDF)

View full-size figure (new tab)

Numerical certificate I.6.2: Moving-frame correction

The reported residual for the complete equation in the moving frame was \(1.0645\times10^{-10}\). Omitting the connection increased the residual to \(0.7000\).

I.6.2 A canonical projector connection

Let \(P_1(t),\ldots,P_m(t)\) be differentiable on an open real time interval, with \(P_a(t)^*=P_a(t)\) and

\[ P_aP_b=\delta_{ab}P_a, \qquad \sum_aP_a=I. \]

Theorem I.6.3: Canonical packet connection

Define

\[ \boxed{ C(t) = \frac12\sum_a[\dot P_a(t),P_a(t)] = \sum_a\dot P_a(t)P_a(t). } \]

Then

\[ C(t)^*=-C(t) \]

and

\[ \boxed{ [C(t),P_b(t)]=\dot P_b(t) } \]

for every packet \(b\).

Proof of Theorem I.6.3

Differentiating \(P_a^2=P_a\) gives

\[ \dot P_aP_a+P_a\dot P_a=\dot P_a. \]

Summing over \(a\) and using \(\sum_a\dot P_a=0\) yields

\[ \sum_aP_a\dot P_a=-\sum_a\dot P_aP_a, \]

which proves both displayed formulas for \(C\) and its skew-Hermiticity.

For fixed \(b\),

\[ CP_b=\dot P_bP_b. \]

When \(a\ne b\), differentiating \(P_bP_a=0\) gives

\[ P_b\dot P_a=-\dot P_bP_a. \]

Hence

\[ P_bC =\sum_aP_b\dot P_aP_a =-\dot P_b(I-P_b), \]

and subtraction gives \([C,P_b]=\dot P_b\).

The connection generates infinitesimal transport of the moving packet frame. The packet family determines it directly, so its construction does not require a basis inside any packet.

I.6.3 Projector curvature

Classical input I.6.4: Projected connection

Let \(M\) be a smooth finite-dimensional real manifold without boundary, let \(V\) be a finite-dimensional real normed vector space, and let \(P:M\to\operatorname{End}_{{\mathbb R}}(V)\) be smooth with \(P(x)^2=P(x)\). In the quantum application, \(V\) is the underlying real space of a finite complex Hilbert space and \(P\) is an orthogonal complex-linear projector.

The rank of \(P\) is locally constant. On each open rank region, its ranges form a smooth vector bundle. For a smooth range section \(s\), so that \(Ps=s\), define

\[ \nabla_Xs=P\,ds(X). \]

This is a connection on smooth range sections. For smooth vector fields \(X,Y\), its curvature satisfies

\[ \boxed{ (\nabla_X\nabla_Y-\nabla_Y\nabla_X-\nabla_{[X,Y]})s =P[dP(X),dP(Y)]P\,s. } \]

Equivalently, its endomorphism-valued curvature is

\[ \boxed{F=P(dP\wedge dP)P.} \]

No global frame or globally constant rank is required, and the vector fields need not commute. The geometric formalization concerns real smooth structures. It does not cover complex analytic manifolds or extensions to a boundary.

Proof of Classical input I.6.4

Range coordinates. Fix \(a\in M\) and put

\[ T_a(x)=P(x)P(a)+(I-P(x))(I-P(a)). \]

Then \(T_a(a)=I\) and \(P(x)T_a(x)=T_a(x)P(a)\). Invertibility is open, so on a neighborhood of \(a\), \(T_a(x)\) restricts to an isomorphism from \({\operatorname{Ran}} P(a)\) to \({\operatorname{Ran}} P(x)\). This proves local constancy of rank. The local coordinates and their transitions are

\[ (x,v)\longmapsto (x,T_a(x)^{-1}v),\qquad u\longmapsto T_b(x)^{-1}T_a(x)u. \]

Their smoothness follows from smoothness of \(P\) and inversion. The transition maps satisfy the cocycle identity by cancellation. These charts construct the smooth range bundles on the open rank regions, including when different connected components have different ranks.

Connection rules. Smoothness of \(P\,ds(X)\) and \(P^2=P\) show that \(\nabla_Xs\) is a smooth range section. Differentiation and projection give

\[ \begin{aligned} \nabla_{X+Y}s&=\nabla_Xs+\nabla_Ys,& \nabla_{fX}s&=f\nabla_Xs,\\ \nabla_X(s+t)&=\nabla_Xs+\nabla_Xt,& \nabla_X(fs)&=f\nabla_Xs+(Xf)s \end{aligned} \]

for smooth real \(f\). The range coordinates above identify ambient smooth range sections with smooth sections of the constructed bundle.

Curvature. Differentiating \(P^2=P\) gives \(P(dP(X))P=0\). Write \(D_Xs=ds(X)\). For ambient smooth sections,

\[ D_XD_Ys-D_YD_Xs-D_{[X,Y]}s=0. \]

Expansion of the projected derivatives therefore leaves

\[ R(X,Y)s=P(dP(X))D_Ys-P(dP(Y))D_Xs. \]

Since \(Ps=s\), differentiation gives \(D_Ys=(dP(Y))s+PD_Ys\). The terms with a middle \(P\) vanish. Thus

\[ R(X,Y)s=P\bigl(dP(X)dP(Y)-dP(Y)dP(X)\bigr)P\,s. \]

This expression is alternating and bilinear in the tangent vectors, and it preserves the range. The ordinary chain rule and the transformation law for the Lie bracket make the local calculations agree on chart overlaps, which gives the global formula.

For an orthogonal rank-one complex projector, use the scalar connection convention \(A=-i\langle u,du\rangle\) in a local unit frame. The associated scalar curvature density is

\[ {\mathcal F}_{\mu\nu} =-i{\operatorname{Tr}}\left(P[\partial_\mu P,\partial_\nu P]\right). \]

On the Bloch sphere,

\[ P(\theta,\phi) = \frac12\left(I+\mathbf n(\theta,\phi)\cdot\boldsymbol\sigma\right), \]

where

\[ \mathbf n=(\sin\theta\cos\phi,\sin\theta\sin\phi,\cos\theta). \]

The Pauli multiplication law gives

\[ [\partial_\theta P,\partial_\phi P] =\frac{i}{2}(\partial_\theta\mathbf n\mathbin{\times}\partial_\phi\mathbf n)\cdot\boldsymbol\sigma. \]

Using \({\operatorname{Tr}}(P\,\mathbf a\cdot\boldsymbol\sigma)=\mathbf n\cdot\mathbf a\) therefore yields

\[ \boxed{{\mathcal F}_{\theta\phi} =\frac12\mathbf n\cdot(\partial_\theta\mathbf n\mathbin{\times}\partial_\phi\mathbf n) =\frac12\sin\theta.} \]

The scalar sign changes if the opposite convention for \(A\) is chosen. This explicit calculation is not a separate entry among the 19 items in the Lean register.

Finite-difference Bloch curvature agrees with the half-sine density.
The curvature of the Bloch projector, evaluated by finite differences, is compared with the exact density \(\frac12\sin\theta\).
Text description

The plot compares the finite-difference curvature and the exact one-half sine-of-theta curve over the displayed polar-angle interval. Both rise to a central peak and fall to zero at the endpoints, with the curves visually coincident at this scale.

Open original figure (PDF)

View full-size figure (new tab)

Numerical certificate I.6.5: Geometric packet identities

The canonical connection reconstructed every packet derivative with residual \(0\). The maximum residual for the Bloch curvature was \(2.0803\times10^{-11}\).

Source and conversion record

Source SHA-256: f4fb9d650bb8f6a7a9b6ccdd04882b4c165566f81c962f4765983b0ce77714b9

Unsupported prose commands stop the build. The mathematical expression sequence is checked against the source, with manuscript macros expanded for display.

Conversion records

Notation in Paper VII

Look up a symbol without leaving this chapter. Select text before opening help to search for it.

Search this work’s notation.

    Symbols can have different meanings in different passages. Read each result in its own context.

    Open the full notation index